7 Freshly Baked Cookie Boxes to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth (Healthier Options Included)

7 Freshly Baked Cookie Boxes to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth (Healthier Options Included)

The aroma of the freshly baked cookies wafting straight from the kitchen is a complete delight.

Freshly baked cookie boxes are an amazing gift for any occasion. Whether it's a birthday, holiday, or just to say, 'thank you', these cookie boxes are sure to please. Gift boxes are available in a variety of sizes and styles, so you can customize the perfect package. The cookies themselves can be made to suit your needs - choose from classic flavors like chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin or create something unique with creative combinations like snickerdoodle and peanut butter. Freshly baked cookie boxes make great gifts that show how much you care. They also make a delicious treat for yourself - no one has to know!

These are rich, crispy, crumbly, and gooey. We have rounded up 7 gourmet cookie brands with a variety of sweet treats. From classic chocolate chip to homemade butter cookies to stuffed cookies, we’ve got all the choices. It will seal the deal- subscription included, meaning a new delicious selection of cookies each month. Order for yourself or send a box as a gift!

For more sweet treats, make sure to check out the list of brands offering gluten-free desserts and vegan desserts.

1. The Very Best Cookie In The Whole Wide World‍

Price: Get cookies starting at $25 (pack of 6)

If you want or send the freshest cookies possible, nothing beats- The Very Best Cookie In The Whole Wide World. As the name suggests, the cookies are delicious and freshly baked to order in Los Angeles.

Founder Kirstyn Shaw perfected the recipe for the chocolate chip cookie for probably a decade. In April 2020, the pandemic turned her side hobby into a thriving business.

The Very Best Cookies

With the highest-quality ingredients, there are a lot of flavors to discover on the cookie menu. Check out The O.G (also known as The Very Best Cookie In The Whole Wide World), I want it All, Triple Threat, The Buttah Pecan, The Cinner, The O.G (Gluten-Free), The Peanut Butteriest, and more tasteful delights.

What is special about the very best cookie? 

The cookie dough rests for a couple of days, which helps flavors to caramelize and develop. In it go chocolate chip and two different kinds of Belgian chocolate that make the whole cookie chocolatey. In the end, it is topped with sea salt to balance out all that chocolate.

For the ultimate chocolate chip cookie experience, bake the cookie dough in the comfort of your home. Get one dozen frozen cookie dough portions for $39. It includes parchment paper to bake on and sea salt to sprinkle on the cookies before you pop them in the oven.

2. Southern Home Bakery‍

Price: Get cookies starting at $3

Classic and delicious are the words to describe when enjoying cookies from Southern Home Bakery. The menu includes custom cookies, gourmet cookies, and bars.

Southern Home Bakery Cookies

They have an impressive variety of flavors for Gourmet cookies. You can shop for chocolate chip gourmet cookies, pumpkin spice gourmet cookies, triple chocolate gourmet cookies, sugar sprinkled gourmet cookie, peanut butter cookie, oatmeal raisin gourmet cookie, and more.

What do you get with Southern Home Bakery Subscription?

Each cookie carton includes an assortment of 6 themed decorated sugar cookies, 4 gourmet cookies, and 4 packs of colorful dots. Indulge in the monthly sweet treat or send these as a gift. These cookies are baked from scratch and hand-decorated according to the monthly theme.

3. Cookie Cottage

Price: Get a dozen cookies for $17

Imagine receiving perfectly baked golden-brown cookies straight from the oven, tempted?

Cookie Cottage offers something for everyone from classic chocolate cookies to nutty cookies. Baked with the finest ingredients and a treasured collection of recipes, you are in for a mouth-watering experience in every bite.

Based in Indiana, Cookie Cottage was founded by two sisters back in 1989 with the business based on family values and a commitment to the community and customers.

Cookie Cottage Varieties

You can shop crispier cookies in flavors of chocolate, iced assortment, nutty cookies, and not-so-nutty. They also have a signature assortment box that features a variety of popular cookie flavors.

Other than these, you can try cookie cakes, brownies (with a moist, fudge-like texture, these are a delightful treat), personalized cookies, and Georgie pies. 

What do you get with Cookie Cottage Subscription?

Cookie Cottage Subscription is everything that a cookie lover could want. Just pick the box size and choice of flavors to build your box. Select up to six different cookie flavors and enjoy the ultimate indulgent treat.

4. Cookie DŌ NYC

Price: Get Cookie DŌ starting at $30

Just like the name suggests, Cookie DŌ is your go-to place to relish the dough-ey goodness of the unbaked cookie. The coolest part is that you can shop for the best cookie dough, cookies, cookie cakes, baking mixes and flour, and other baking kits.

The perfect recipes for the cookie flavors are prepared after a lot of research with tested and tried ingredients to suit all dietary restrictions. DŌ's spoon-ready deliciousness comes in more than 10 flavors.

Cookie DŌ Varieties

They have a variety of boxes such as build your cookie box, variety pack cookie box, classic chocolate chip cookie box, gluten-free cookie box, variety pack cookie box & edible cookie dough bundle, and more.

What do you get with Cookie DŌ NYC Subscription?

Join The Cookie Dough Club and treat yourself to a monthly subscription of cookie doughliciousness delivered into cardboard boxes straight to your doorstep. You get new flavors and packs, free shipping, a package that includes 4 containers, and a special surprise each month.

5. Coco Bakes

Price: Get cookies starting at $24 (pack of 12)

Who said cookies can't be healthy and delicious? Coco Bakes has exactly these with thin crispy edges and chewy middle. If you love cookies that look as good as they taste, you are in for a treat with Coco Bakes.

Coco Bakes Cookies                               

They source the best quality, organic ingredients for gluten-free, dairy-free, and soy-free cookies. You can choose from salted peanut butter chocolate chip cookies, snickerdoodle peanut butter cookies, caramel cookies, and spice cookies. Other than these, you can also shop for bars, bread, and cakes.

6. A Bite of Pie

Price: Get cookies starting at $20

With the sweet and warm smell of freshly baked bakery-style cookies, you won't be able to resist your hands from getting yourself a bite of it.

Freshly baked desserts from A Bite of Pie are made with the finest quality ingredients produced locally. The bakery has been in service for almost two decades and initially started as a fundraiser to raise money to buy Christmas gifts for the less fortunate.

A Bite of Pie Varieties

Made in fresh batches, the menu includes cookies, pies, cupcakes, flower bouquets, flower cupcakes, custom print cookies, cheesecakes, and brownies.

Not a fan of gluten? Choose from gluten-free options and enjoy your sweet tooth cravings! 

7. Num Gourmet Desserts

Price: Get cookies starting at $24.50

Everyone deserves to enjoy guilt-free desserts. Well, we got you. Num Gourmet Desserts offers gluten-free treats for your sweet cravings. Here you have desserts made with the finest ingredients that work out well for a gluten-free, diabetic, keto, macro counting, calorie counting, etc. diet. So be free to choose your dessert and indulge in the sea of sweetness!

Owner Brennan was on a weight loss journey and recovering as a sugar addict. Being an emotional eater, a late-night binger, and handling PPD (Purified Protein Derivative) collectively contributed to her unhappy state of mind. To fight her weight loss, she came across the keto lifestyle that changed her life for the better. Living that rollercoaster journey of weight loss, she decided to create a universal healthy snack that anyone can enjoy. That's how the bakery with guilt-free desserts took off as a business.

The menu includes cookies, brownies, pies, and granola bars. Num Gourmet Desserts offers a delightful holiday cookie box that is sure to bring smiles to your friends and family. Each box is filled with an assortment of cookies in various shapes and sizes. You can be sure that each cookie has been carefully crafted ahead of time, using only the finest ingredients. From almond-based treats to delicious candy-coated delights, everyone will find something they love in this festive selection. The cookies are so good that you may even find yourself reaching for seconds! Whether you're looking for a special gift or just want to indulge yourself, Num Gourmet Desserts have something for everyone.

Num Gourmet Dessert Varieties

From classic favorites like chocolate cake and ice cream to more unique creations such as creme brulee and tiramisu, Num Gourmet Dessert Varieties has something for everyone. Their cakes are especially renowned, with a wide range of flavors, fillings, and decorations available. They also offer cupcakes, cookies, brownies, pies, tarts, and other treats. With the variety of options they provide, it's easy to find something special to make your next gathering or event even more memorable. Plus, their desserts are made with only the freshest ingredients to ensure quality and taste every time. For those looking for a unique dessert experience that will impress even the most discerning palate, Num Gourmet Dessert Varieties is the place to go.

Want To Bake Some Handmade Perfect Cookie Boxes At Home?

Baking the perfect cookie doesn’t have to be a daunting task for any festive season. With a few simple steps, you can easily achieve delicious results and make any types of cookies. Start by making a shopping list to make the cookies. Add the flour mixture, baking powder, followed by creaming together with the whisk and stir the butter mixture and sugar with an electric mixer until light and fluffy. Add in the vanilla and beat until combined. Spread out your remaining dough with a spatula onto a lined baking sheet and floured surface, leaving space between each cookie about an inch apart and get them lined with parchment paper. You can also spare some of them into an airtight container. With preservatives, you can save the wholesale even for 3 months.

Put cookies on the tray and add the chocolate chips, nuts like almond, walnut or fruit extracts to decorate the cookies and also for a flavorful surface, carefully place a cover the bowl with a large bowl. Place it in the refrigerator for an hour or two, as it needs to be chilled on sheets with parchment paper before you start baking. Once cooled completely into the fridge, bake your cookies for 12-15 minutes at 350°F or until golden brown on crisp edges and set in the center for a perfect presentation. Allow them to cool before indulging in your perfectly baked cookies that melts in your mouth!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.